Trading Technology

02:01 PM
Beau Alexander
Beau Alexander
Commentary
Connect Directly
LinkedIn
RSS
E-Mail
50%
50%

Why Settle for Less in the Front Office?

Recent research shows that sell-side firms are less than satisfied with their order management system (OMS) technology. Many front offices, however, continue to make do with their current solutions. Are they selling themselves short?

In its recent global survey of brokerage firms and investment banks, TABB Group reveals the sell-side’s “striking level of tepid satisfaction and even outright frustration” with current OMS solutions. It also notes that, by having a more flexible infrastructure and a single point of execution, with execution capabilities for multiple asset classes and global locations, organizations could increase efficiency and reduce their overall trading costs.
 
This best-case scenario, however, appears to contrast sharply with the reality for many investment banks and brokers. Notably, when discussing OMS technologies, one head of equity trading for an agency broker told TABB Group: “None of them are ideal. Unfortunately, you’ve got to pick your poison.”
 
This could be viewed as an extreme comment that reflects the sentiment within today’s front offices when it comes to technology. In times of continued budgetary constraints and margin pressure, there is a tendency to view any large-scale transformation of the technology environment as an expensive headache. The easier option, ostensibly, has been to meet new and specific requirements on a piecemeal basis, as and when they arise: turning to a packaged solution for one asset class here and another there.

[For more on OMS initiatives, read No Rush to Upgrade OMSs Among Sell-Side Firms.]
 
The long-term result of this approach can itself be chronically painful: swiveling between multiple systems to perform tasks, inputting the same data over and over again, and increasing opportunities for manual error. But the front office in particular seems resigned to this far-from-perfect situation. There is also an awareness that, post-trade, the problem is passed elsewhere. What’s bad for the front office in this context will be considerably worse for compliance, the middle office, and beyond.
 
Is a better OMS out there?
An answer, however, is available. The challenge for sell-side firms is to do their research and find a provider that has invested in both its own technology and its future, continually innovating to expand and improve its solutions. It’s also well worth investigating the vendor’s technology partners. Does it, for example, partner with a similarly credible hosting provider or engage with the best performing execution services?
 
In establishing a new technology partnership, the front office has important questions to ask itself, too. Is it carrying excessive overheads? Are too many of its staff employed as stop-gaps to technology? How much of their time could be better repurposed elsewhere? In other words, choosing the right OMS solution is less about picking your poison than making the right decisions. Regardless of the cost and complexity of a migration project, it will certainly be less painful in the long run than limping along with an inefficient combination of inadequate solutions.
 
The new front-office team doesn’t settle
There’s another increasingly important reason for ensuring that front-office teams are working with exactly the right solutions: the changing characteristics of the teams themselves.
 
In the early 2000s, developments in technology and the internet changed the face of trading, but not necessarily the people behind it. Seasoned traders who typically majored in finance or economics gradually had to swap manual tickets and phone orders for keyboards and monitors. More than a decade later, a new generation of the front-office workforce has emerged. While these up-and-coming traders might have a minor in finance, their skills and interests are predominantly focused on math and technology. First and foremost, they understand the algorithms, calculations, and complex data sets that power today’s trading environment.
 
In short, the front-office teams of 2014 have completely different skill sets from those of 10, 20, and 30 years ago. So, when it comes to attracting top talent, a firm that’s operating an outdated, confusing set of technologies is likely to lose out to a competitor with a fully integrated, multi-asset class OMS. The harsh truth is that these high-flying, technology-driven young brokers would never settle for “picking their poison.” Instead, they might just say: “I can’t do what I need to do with this. There must be a better OMS solution out there.” What’s more, they’d almost certainly be right.

Beau Alexander leads the equity product management team for SunGard's Valdi solution, determining the focus and direction of SunGard's equity product line. This strategic role concentrates on industry trends and upcoming opportunities that direct the software development ... View Full Bio
Comment  | 
Print  | 
More Insights
More Commentary
5 Tips On How To Prepare For A Data Breach
If you are a financial institution your cyber security defenses will be breached -- again and again. Here are five tips to respond quickly and minimize damage.
Wall Street CIOs Have a Vendor Management Problem
If Wall Street CIOs want to stay ahead of competition and ensure high-speed trading software doesn't start the next flash crash, they need better insight into vendor delivered software.
Technology Innovation Returns to Financial Services
Capital Markets Outlook 2015: Following a few years dominated by regulatory compliance and cost saving technology initiatives, financial organizations are finally investing in innovative technology and tools.
Voice Biometrics Improve Transaction Monitoring Fraud Detection
Why voice biometrics should be a part of your fraud prevention strategy in the call center.
Fintech Fast Forward 2015
What will shape the future of Fintech in 2015 and beyond?
Register for Wall Street & Technology Newsletters
White Papers
Current Issue
Wall Street & Technology - Elite 8, October 2014
The in-depth profiles of this year's Elite 8 honorees focus on leadership, talent recruitment, big data, analytics, mobile, and more.
Video
Exclusive: Inside the GETCO Execution Services Trading Floor
Exclusive: Inside the GETCO Execution Services Trading Floor
Advanced Trading takes you on an exclusive tour of the New York trading floor of GETCO Execution Services, the solutions arm of GETCO.