Trading Technology

09:40 AM
Greg MacSweeney
Greg MacSweeney
Connect Directly

HFT Profits Shrinking? The Data Doesn't Lie

Whether high-frequency trading is good for investors or bad, one fact that no one disputes is the drastic drop in HFT profits.

When people argue, the best debaters usually have a good grasp of the data that can support their arguments. Whether it's about who's better (Mays or Mantle) or which phone is more popular (iPhone or Galaxy S III), people point to stats and data to support their arguments.

HFT Loses Its LusterThe April 2013 digital issue of Advanced Trading takes an in-depth look at how the fall in trading volume and volatility are forcing high-frequency trading firms to look for new markets and innovate. To read more, download our April 2013 digital issue now.

Willie Mays hit more home runs, but he played longer; Mickey Mantle, on the other hand, had many injuries, but he won more World Series titles. The iPhone is the best selling smartphone of all time. The Galaxy S III, however, is rapidly gaining market share.

When it comes to high-frequency trading, the debaters also point to stats and data to make their arguments, both for and against the controversial practice. Proponents claim that HFT players are the new market makers, providing liquidity to the marketplace, and that spreads have tightened since Regulation NMS -- both beneficial to investors. Opponents argue that spreads haven't actually decreased since Reg NMS and that the liquidity isn't genuine and can quickly evaporate in times of crisis, such as the 2010 flash crash.

So what is the truth? Everyone is using the same market data, yet each is reaching very different conclusions. Is the data lying, or is the interpretation of the data at fault? Both arguments are convincing, but which should we believe? Entire books have been written pillorying HFT based on data analysis and research. Other books, pulling from the same data, make HFT seem like the greatest thing since sliced bread.

A Shrinking Market

Whether high-frequency trading is good for investors or bad, one fact that no one disputes is the drastic drop in HFT profits. As market volatility has declined and volumes plummeted, the amount of money to be made from HFT strategies has fallen as well. For instance, overall U.S. equity trading volume is down more than 33% since 2009, according to TABB Group. This results in fewer opportunities for HFT strategies to capitalize on market movements.

[HFT Demise as the Precursor to Changes in the Markets Landscape ]

Just how much smaller are the profits? Well, for GETCO, the largest HFT player in the U.S. markets, profits from HFT shrank 82% last year, down $110.2 million from 2011. That's staggering.

Profits from all market participants using high-frequency trading strategies dropped to $1 billion last year, reportedly down from $5 billion just four years ago.

Does this mean HFT will disappear? No, certainly not. However, the game has shifted. No longer can anyone with a server, an algo and some capital enter the high-frequency trading space and expect to compete. It appears that the market will be dominated by larger organizations that have the ability to invest in technology and continually improve their strategy.

Despite one's views on the pros and cons of high-frequency trading, the data shows that profits from the practice are shrinking, and so is the number of competitors. And in this case, the data doesn't lie.

Greg MacSweeney is editorial director of InformationWeek Financial Services, whose brands include Wall Street & Technology, Bank Systems & Technology, Advanced Trading, and Insurance & Technology. View Full Bio
Comment  | 
Print  | 
More Insights
Newest First  |  Oldest First  |  Threaded View
User Rank: Apprentice
3/18/2013 | 8:24:53 PM
re: HFT Profits Shrinking? The Data Doesn't Lie
Gosh, that's a shame. Couldn't happen to a nicer group of guys . . .

User Rank: Apprentice
3/18/2013 | 8:24:53 PM
re: HFT Profits Shrinking? The Data Doesn't Lie
Gosh, that's a shame. Couldn't happen to a nicer group of guys . . .

User Rank: Apprentice
3/18/2013 | 7:00:30 PM
re: HFT Profits Shrinking? The Data Doesn't Lie
i believe human traders have also started to learn(hopefully) that the intraday game is not working anymore and moving up to larger timeframes.

i believe humans will adapt to this HFT monster fuelled by greed.(it is a great hope)

its good to see their profits drop so much. makes it less worth the infrastructure costs.
More Commentary
Chief Data Officers: Organization Strategy & Cultural Change
Chief data officers are new to the financial services C-suite, but they are facing a number of challenges, including the need for new data governance and execution strategies, staffing, and new organizational structures to enable cultural change.
New York FinTech Innovation Lab Calls for New Entrepreneurial Applicants
Wells Fargo joins 14 other major financial institutions providing mentoring and guidance to the six chosen startups.
Micro Data Challenges in an Era of Macroprudential Regulation
Research and statistical analysis experts at central banks are tasked with developing sophisticated forecasts and models to identify systemic risk. Yet they are spending most of their time acting as data entry clerks, rather than developing these models.
The Perks of 'SmartSourcing' Shared Services in Financial Industry
A breadth of vital but undifferentiated business processes are still being replicated across the industry. They are all candidates for centralization.
Managing Social Media Risk Strategy: Technology Can Only Go So Far
Advanced analytical technologies are an important part of a social media risk management strategy, an Accenture report says, but the technology must be balanced with training and procedures.
Register for Wall Street & Technology Newsletters
White Papers
Current Issue
Wall Street & Technology - Elite 8, October 2014
The in-depth profiles of this year's Elite 8 honorees focus on leadership, talent recruitment, big data, analytics, mobile, and more.
Exclusive: Inside the GETCO Execution Services Trading Floor
Exclusive: Inside the GETCO Execution Services Trading Floor
Advanced Trading takes you on an exclusive tour of the New York trading floor of GETCO Execution Services, the solutions arm of GETCO.