Trading Technology

09:33 AM
Steve Grob
Steve Grob
Commentary
50%
50%

A Time-Out for HFT

If high frequency traders can submit quotes and pull them out in an instant, why not set a time limit before they can resubmit a new quote?

Good to see that the HFT community is finally starting to educate the regulators and policymakers. As we all know, the debate hinges on whether these firms are really acting as electronic versions of traditional market makers and, if they are, whether they should be subject to some of the same formal market making obligations. In particular, regulators have been gnashing their teeth over the fact that such firms are free to replace their quotes as often, or as "frequently," as they like. The regulators argue that all this activity creates substantial noise that clogs up data pipes and distorts the true picture of the real price of a stock. In their defense, the HFTers argue that they have the right to re-price their "product" just as often as market conditions dictate and that, anyway, they aren't breaking any laws.

This prompted me to ask a friend about how all this worked in the good old days of manual markets and traditional market makers. In response to this question, he paused for thought and then replied that, in those days, your quote was valid "whilst your breath was still warm."

Basically, this was just a poetic way of saying that it all depended upon a bunch of factors -- how fast markets were moving, the instrument in question, the client, and even the different nature of individual trading floors and exchanges. Seems like the regulators might struggle, then, to impose an absolute time frame for quote validity in today's world as any level is destined to be wrong in most cases, most of the time. If they are determined to impose absolute limits, then why not do it the other way round?

In short, say that HFTers can pull their quotes just as often as they like but there is a certain minimum time period before they can resubmit a quote?

This idea was put to me the other day and, whilst it sounds like a subtle change, it would seem to provide a fair and equitable solution to the problems of both the HFTers (namely having to trade on a bad or stale quote) and the trading community at large (noise and clogged data pipes).

Irrespective of the merits of this approach, solutions that are fair and equitable on all market participants should be the mantra of the regulators. This means divorcing themselves from the politicians and accepting that perhaps the best they can ever hope to achieve is a solution that leaves everyone equally unhappy.

Steve Grob is director at Fidessa and he regularly writes for the firm's Fragmentation blog.

Comment  | 
Print  | 
More Insights
More Commentary
The Mainframe Innovation Drag
It may be time for a consortium of firms motivated around the objective of eliminating the mainframe. What if every self-clearing firm decided to participate in building a modern, back-office system as an open-source, cloud-based project?
Big Data DIY
Now that we have passed the initial hype phase of big data, companies are searching for real business value from their investments. Consultants can play a part, but only if financial firms insist on a new partnership model.
Surviving & Thriving in the Current Risk Management & Regulatory Environment
How financial institutions can leverage compliance initiatives to improve their business with a 360-degree view of the customer.
Markets Looking Forward to Earnings
Geopolitical risks are increasing as the markets chug through the summer months, and investors are watching their risk profiles very closely.
5 Red Hot Summer Market Predictions
With the summer starting to heat up, here are five things we will see in the financial markets in the second half of 2014.
Register for Wall Street & Technology Newsletters
White Papers
Current Issue
Wall Street & Technology - July 2014
In addition to regular audits, the SEC will start to scrutinize the cyber-security preparedness of market participants.
Video
Exclusive: Inside the GETCO Execution Services Trading Floor
Exclusive: Inside the GETCO Execution Services Trading Floor
Advanced Trading takes you on an exclusive tour of the New York trading floor of GETCO Execution Services, the solutions arm of GETCO.