12:50 PM
Ivy Schmerken
Ivy Schmerken
Connect Directly

Disclosing Dark Pool Volumes, Only A Matter of Time

A panel of Wall Street executives warmed up to the idea of reporting dark pool volumes on a monthly basis, as they debated U.S. equity market structure.

Several Wall Street executives voiced their support for disclosure of dark pool trading volumes, a step that regulators are reportedly considering as U.S. exchanges complain about the loss of volume.

At a Tabb Forum event on Tuesday night, sell side traders debated the pros and cons of U.S. equity market structure and whether there was a better model elsewhere in the world.

The idea of publishing dark liquidity on a monthly or bi-monthly basis in an aggregated format came up several times on the panel, and was favored in contrast to any "brute force" rules.

“We don’t have good data on dark liquidity,” said Dave Weisberger, with Two Sigma Securities, the broker dealer unit of quantitative hedge fund Two Sigma Investments, which acts as a wholesaler for retail order flow. “I haven’t talked to anybody that’s against it,” said Weisberger. “Why doesn’t the market implement a rule that tells us what percentage of their volume is in dark pool vs. exchanges.

“We think that disclosure is the most logical step,” said Vlad Khandros, market structure and liquidity analysis, at UBS Investment Bank, noting that it could be monthly or biweekly. Khandros said that UBS has gone on the record endorsing greater disclose on dark pools.

The over arching theme of the panel, entitled “Continental Divide,” was how to achieve the best market structure for lit and dark markets and what impact that would have on price formation and order competition. Panelists discussed whether or not the U.S. equity market should adopt regulations such as the Trade At rule that was adopted in Canada and Australia.

However, sparks erupted when Sal Arnuk, partner in institutional agency broker Themis Trading, pointed out some of the weaknesses in the current electronic trading market. “Institutions ironically are migrating to dark markets to escape the shenanigans of lit markets, “ said Arnuk, adding that "The lit exchanges are dominated by a game of rebate arbitrage," referring to high frequency trading strategies.

Arnuk said he’d like to see more disclosure on price/time priority. Given the lack of disclosure, Arnuk said buy side firms rely on tags coming back telling participants in dark pools whether the other side is an algo or high frequency trading firm, he said.

Two Sigma’s Weisberger agreed with Arnuk that “ATS rules should be made public, and he also cited the need for good data on dark liquidity. “Why doesn’t the market implement a rule that tells us what percent of their volume is in dark pools vs. exchanges,” suggested Weisberger.

Defending dark pools, Khandros pointed out that dark pools are part of best execution. Tabb Group’s Senior Analyst Sayena Mostowfi cited new rules governing dark pools implemented last October by Canada and Australia in June of 2013. The rules require that dark pools give meaningful price improvement over the displayed market’s quotes, as a way to stem the flow of volume back to exchanges. While Canada and Australia present case studies, the jury is still out. However, Khandros panned the Canadian results, noting that since Canada implemented a rule similar to the U.S. “Trade-At” rule, the firms that are trading more and becoming more profitable are a handful of prop shops. "There is a transfer of volume from retail investors to prop shops and not to exchanges,” said Khandros.

There were some tense moments in the discussion as when Arnuk talked about fragmentation as a problem but Direct Edge's chief of Strategy, Anthony Barchetto, said that fragmentation in any other industry was regarded as a sign of competition. And when Arnuk said that exchanges had experienced a dramatic evolution in terms of less diversity in their order books, Barchetto fired back that his exchange is diverse. "It's a lot more diverse with HFT, arbitrage, bulge bracket, agency brokers. Forty-five percent of the volume everyday is not related to the rebate."

Ivy is Editor-at-Large for Advanced Trading and Wall Street & Technology. Ivy is responsible for writing in-depth feature articles, daily blogs and news articles with a focus on automated trading in the capital markets. As an industry expert, Ivy has reported on a myriad ... View Full Bio
Comment  | 
Print  | 
More Insights
Newest First  |  Oldest First  |  Threaded View
User Rank: Author
6/14/2013 | 9:09:12 PM
re: Disclosing Dark Pool Volumes, Only A Matter of Time
Disclosing dark pool volumes, even in an aggregated form, could be a way to stave off more intrusive rules. Or, at least, it gives regulators better data on stocks trading in dark vs. lit markets. Investors would also gain visibility into the data. Seems fair since it's their orders that are being routed.
Greg MacSweeney
Greg MacSweeney,
User Rank: Apprentice
6/14/2013 | 1:16:13 PM
re: Disclosing Dark Pool Volumes, Only A Matter of Time
Dark markets definitely serve their purpose and many large investors are using them (with good success). With more volume moving to dark pools, the regulators have no choice to start monitoring activity. If the regulators do not monitor activity and there is a problem down the road, investors will scream that regulators were asleep at the switch. So, like it or not, dark markets will become a little more lit.
More Commentary
Predictions Come True as Regulators Swoop
While two out of the five capital markets predictions from July have already come true, let's hope that all five don't actually happen.
IBOR Before It Was "IBOR"
While its catchy new nomenclature and explosion in popularity has given the outside world an impression that it is novel, the same conversations about it were happening twenty years ago. So why then is IBOR the latest buzz word for firms today?
SEC Reforms: What Floating NAVs Mean for Money Market Funds & Accounting Software
Money market accounts are a $2.6 trillion industry that impacts nearly every investor who parks cash, so a new SEC rule has major ramifications for a large number of investors.
Flip Sides of the Same Coin: Compliance & Transparency
The upheaval caused by the 2008 financial crisis continues to ripple outward, creating an unsettled environment that has disrupted traditional measures of trust.
IT Budgets Struggle With Data Growth, Survey Finds
Data is growing exponentially and IT managers are worried about budgeting for future storage. More sustainable solutions must come from the business lines.
Register for Wall Street & Technology Newsletters
White Papers
Current Issue
Wall Street & Technology - July 2014
In addition to regular audits, the SEC will start to scrutinize the cyber-security preparedness of market participants.
Exclusive: Inside the GETCO Execution Services Trading Floor
Exclusive: Inside the GETCO Execution Services Trading Floor
Advanced Trading takes you on an exclusive tour of the New York trading floor of GETCO Execution Services, the solutions arm of GETCO.