Data Management

08:51 AM
Brooke Allen
Brooke Allen
Connect Directly

Can We Do Better? Stealing Other People's Property

Banks have long been creating products that are so complex that clients, risk managers and even some of the firm's own salespeople can't understand what is actually in them.

When you create a something so complex that it is hard to understand, it becomes easy to steal things that do not belong to you.

In my prior piece, Can We Do Better? Bad Parenting I said, "I think a fundamental problem of our industry is that the concept of property has become so abstracted and ambiguous that it can become unclear who owns what. Some people think that if title isn't pinned down then it is OK to pocket something that does not belong to them."

This needs clarification. What do I mean by abstracted and ambiguous property?

When I leave for home at 4:30, I look out the window at the offices of sell-side firms that will be lit up into the wee hours by people hunkered down creating products with so many pieces that nobody is able to price or keep track of them properly. I know because I have worked at some of those firms.

Example 1: In days of yore, you could often get a better execution for a market order than you would expect from the publicly displayed quote. The right to "price improvement" belongs to the person generating the order; but frequently the broker would fill you at the quote and keep the price improvement, or sell his order flow to someone who would.

Example 2: When you display a limit order to "Buy" you are writing a put option to all who see it. Conversely, a "Sell" order creates a call option. The writer does not receive a premium. Instead the value accrues to the person who uses these orders to stop their losses.

Example 3: Banks securitize mortgages and sell them into the markets rather than carry them on their balance sheets and thus creating an imbedded option to walk away from responsibility. They sell everything else and keep that option for themselves. The option to walk away has tremendous value; just ask anyone who is fighting over alimony and child support how much they would pay to just walk away.

In extreme cases, such as Example 3, some people can get stuck holding the bag who hadn't signed up for such duty. Can you guess who they are? Hint: The answer begins with "Tax" and ends with "ayers.”

Brooke Allen is a 30-year industry veteran who most recently founded a quantitative trading desk now celebrating its 17th year in continuous operation. For years he wrote a monthly piece for International Family Magazine, in 2009 he founded to discuss ... View Full Bio
Comment  | 
Print  | 
More Insights
More Commentary
Why Settle for Less in the Front Office?
Recent research shows that sell-side firms are less than satisfied with their order management system (OMS) technology. Many front offices, however, continue to make do with their current solutions. Are they selling themselves short?
BYOD Policy: Don't Reinvent the Wheel
Financial firms still feel overwhelmed by BYOD risks and challenges. But these can be addressed by a good policy, and the guidelines are already out there.
The BYOD Challenge
Having a policy in place to manage mobile devices used by employees for work purposes is necessary in this current day.
Getting Onboarding Right in the Age of the Customer
Disparate “Frankenstein” systems slow down the onboarding process and impede customer service, says Pegasystems.
Performance Monitoring Key to Smooth Infrastructure Modernization
As banks consider how to shift infrastructure and storage solutions, they can’t afford to lose visibility into performance.
Register for Wall Street & Technology Newsletters
White Papers
Current Issue
Wall Street & Technology - July 2014
In addition to regular audits, the SEC will start to scrutinize the cyber-security preparedness of market participants.
5 Things to Look For Before Accepting Terms & Conditions
5 Things to Look For Before Accepting Terms & Conditions
Is your corporate data at risk? Before uploading sensitive information to cloud services be sure to review these terms.