Compliance

09:00 AM
Doug Engmann
Doug Engmann
Commentary
Connect Directly
LinkedIn
RSS
E-Mail
50%
50%

Raising the Bar on Co-Location for All Trading Firms

Any high-frequency trading firm that co-locates its servers at an exchange should have formal market-making responsibilities, be registered as a broker dealer, and be tracked for compliance with SEC rules.

There has been much discussion about the practice of co-location by exchanges as a crucial factor in high-speed trading in equities and options. Many commentators have said that the time, speed, and information advantage inherent in co-location has been in existence as long as exchanges have been trading. This had been true for many years and through different iterations of market structure, but these commentators fail to recognize the different conditions in which this practice took place.

Floor traders always had a time and place advantage in the equity or options markets. By being present on the floor where orders were being held and executed physically, they could act before that information left the floor. Even with the advent of electronic trading and the maintenance of electronic order books, access to the depth in the order book was restricted to certain persons registered as market makers or specialists.

However, the exchanges and the SEC imposed stringent requirements on those present on the floor. Floor traders, brokers, market makers, and specialists all had to be broker dealers; they were registered with the exchange and were subject to its regulatory scrutiny. Most importantly, market makers and specialists had affirmative obligations to make two-sided markets in the products they were trading. This provided liquidity to the customers of the exchange. Furthermore, floor brokers and traders/specialists/market makers had stringent rules about front running, trading ahead, and customer priority. All these issues draw complaints today about HFT practices by firms that are not broker dealers or subject to similar exchange oversight.

We could debate how effective these rules were in corralling unethical or illegal practices, such as trading ahead of your customer, or in ensuring a liquid market in times of volatility. But at least the principle was that traders with built-in advantages would have regulatory responsibilities that would be monitored by the exchanges.

However, with demutualization, the exchanges have substituted cash for regulatory responsibility as the tradeoff for firms wanting that time and place advantage. They gain that advantage by co-locating their servers on the new "floors" -- the server rooms of each exchange. The SEC recently fined the NYSE for allowing this practice without submitting a rule change to the commission, but it did not deal with the lack of regulatory responsibility associated with the practice of co-location.

Any trading firm at any exchange that wants co-location in an exchange's server room should have formal market-making responsibilities, be registered as a broker dealer, and be actively monitored for compliance with exchange and SEC rules. All others should be required to go through a broker. If that broker wants to co-locate its servers in the exchange's server room, it would be placed where it is at a slight millisecond disadvantage to the registered firms that are making markets.

The return of SEC registration and market-making responsibilities might not solve all the issues being raised by the market structure the SEC has created. However, it would be a big step in dealing with the time and place advantage that is now being sold to the highest bidder without any respect for the market responsibilities traditionally associated with that privilege.

Doug Engmann is President of Engmann Options Inc., a San Francisco private investment and securities consulting firm owned by the Engmann brothers, and Chairman of Sage Brokerage Holdings, LLC which is the parent of a broker-dealer servicing active professional traders. He ... View Full Bio
Comment  | 
Print  | 
More Insights
Comments
Oldest First  |  Newest First  |  Threaded View
IvySchmerken
50%
50%
IvySchmerken,
User Rank: Author
5/31/2014 | 2:11:19 PM
Obligations for HFT?
Doug, you are suggsting that high frequency trading firms should have market-making obligations since they are benefiting from colocation, which gives them a time and place advantage today, without any obligations. 

You are suggesting that if HFTs don't register as broker dealers they should have a one milisecond disadvantage in the colo data center, whereas those who register as b-ds would have a speed advantage. Today, colocation supposedly gives everyone equal access. This would require shaking up the colocation rules so that speed of access is correlated with broker-registration.

I think today, those HFTs that are not registered as broker dealers have a  sponsored access agreement with a broker dealer or clearing firm. So they are gaining  privledges to access the market through that a clearing/credit risk relationship.

 
More Commentary
Shared Reporting Services on the Horizon, Genpact Predicts
The financial services industry is starting to adopt shared services, resulting in reasonable impacts to the bottom line. Genpact expects a push for reporting efficiency will come next.
Don't Let the Cloud Rain on Your Operations Strategy Parade
Avoid migrating large applications all at once to minimize risk during a cloud project.
Could Intel Lose Data Center Market Share to ARM Chips?
ARM chips could be an alternative for certain purposes in the datacenter, but many questions have to be answered before they pose a threat to Intel's market dominance.
Cost to Trade: Hey, Banks, Itís Time to Face the Music
Why is calculating the cost to trade so difficult for banks? The answer is as complex as the calculations themselves.
M&A Activity Will Continue to Grow in 2015
Data shows that the M&A market continues to improve, and forecasts indicate deal making will be healthy in 2015.
Register for Wall Street & Technology Newsletters
White Papers
Current Issue
Wall Street & Technology - Elite 8, October 2014
The in-depth profiles of this year's Elite 8 honorees focus on leadership, talent recruitment, big data, analytics, mobile, and more.
Video
Stressed Out by Compliance, Reputational Damage & Fines?
Stressed Out by Compliance, Reputational Damage & Fines?
Financial services executives are living in a "regulatory pressure cooker." Here's how executives are preparing for the new compliance requirements.