09:28 AM
Javier Paz, Aite Group
Javier Paz, Aite Group

Bank Of England Governor Grilled About FX Fixing Scandal

Governor voes to root out bank collusion and sharing of confidential deal information between dealers and customers.

Javier Paz, Aite Group
Javier Paz, Aite Group

Despite the still-unfolding London FX fixing scandal and its ramifications in other major global FX centers, I venture to say that Mark Carney, the Bank of England's governor,still enjoys plenty of general support for his courage (folly?) to accomplish unenviable tasks such as setting aright the U.K.’s monetary policy, maintaining London’s reputation in financial circles, and correcting oversight problems in the functioning of over-the-counter markets.

Carney’s Monday grilling by the House of Commons Treasury Committee — and it was a grilling — tested the BOE governor’s suave demeanor multiple times. What drew my attention was not Carney’s command of the problem or of the before and after of a BOE staff member suspension (he did fine on both accounts) but rather the fact that the Bank of England has been placed on the defensive. Treasury Committee members bashed the BOE for not picking up on now compromising comments recorded during four-to-six FX committee meetings (and for not escalating these issues over more than five years), for failing to look at similar problems in different markets (such gold and swaps), for having "at the heart … a governance structure that is still opaque, complex, and byzantine [that] desperately needs to be sorted out."

While Carney made it clear that the roles of market surveillance and conduct investigation are under the purview of the Financial Conduct Authority, he subtly suggested he would be involved in international efforts to institute more fair play to preserve the credibility of capital markets and root out two core issues in the FX scandal: (1) collusion by dealing banks and (2) sharing of confidential-deal information for a particular client among banks or to bankers’ top clients/prospects. Monday revealed that a Lloyds’ senior dealer allegedly tipped off a British Petroleum dealer colleague and client of a large (and still pending) Lloyds FX transaction, causing the trader to be one more of two dozen or so bankers across the industry who have been suspended over the past month or two for their involvement in clubby, allegedly improper, FX dealing activities.

The fallout from these developing events will very likely dramatically alter OTC FX operations in coming years. Discretion and trader communication oversight will be important themes going forward. To begin with, banks will institute their own measures to regulate and curtail dealing activity, both internally and externally. Certain of these measures will completely redraw how OTC traders are able to communicate, what they can and cannot say, and how such activity will be monitored.

The changes may address some of today’s problems, but they could also introduce new risks, such as lower bank willingness to take on large deals (i.e., lower liquidity) during a time of macro-instability and less willingness to talk about industry problems.

Now that banks know that the BOE and other central bankers are closely monitoring bank OTC activities, we can safely expect less candid discussions at central bank-sponsored FX committees meetings. While discretion is usually a praiseworthy attribute, the kind of discretion we are likely to see evolve in OTC markets is not. Carney’s methodical and well-calibrated approach to issue resolution, however, gives me a measure of hope that while more OTC regulatory changes are now inevitable, there’s a chance they might strike a happy equilibrium between zealous and complacent oversight.

About The Author: Javier Paz is a senior analyst at Aite Group within the Wealth Management practice. In this role, Mr. Paz examines retail trading trends in business, regulations, and technology across asset classes. Areas of expertise include FX markets, active trader segmentation, front-end trading technology, and margin-trading regulations. His coverage of retail trading markets is global in nature, with particular emphasis on the United States, Japan, and emerging markets. He has also written about systemic risks facing global capital markets, such as asymmetric FX regimes and cross-asset class contagion.

Comment  | 
Print  | 
More Insights
Newest First  |  Oldest First  |  Threaded View
User Rank: Author
3/17/2014 | 2:27:41 PM
re: Bank Of England Governor Grilled About FX Fixing Scandal
In response to a tougher stance by regulators such as the BOE, several big banks have curtailed their use of certain instant messaging/chat networks to reduce the risk that traders will collude on FX with counterparts at other firms. Yet in an OTC market like FX communication is key. As you say, banks will redraw the lines of communication, what can be said and how it will be monitored. It's a real shake up for the OTC FX market which has enjoyed less regulation than other markets.
More Commentary
Interactive Data Launches Continuous Fixed Income Pricing Service
Independent intra-day FI pricing is helping to shine light on the opaque fixed income market.
Gartner: 75% of Mobile Apps Will Fail Security Tests Through 2015
The rise of BYOD means enterprises must implement security testing and containment solutions, according to new Gartner research.
Chip & Pain, EMV Will Not Solve Payment Card Fraud
Switching to EMV cards will lower retail fraud, but it's not enough. Here's the good, the bad, and the ugly.
With UCITS V, $9T Isnít as Easy as It Used to Be
With UCITS V's restrictive remuneration rules and hidden costs, going global may get a little less attractive.
Banks to Increase IT Spend on Big Data Challenges, Finds Aite Report
Big data has presented the greatest challenges and dissatisfaction for banks, yet it is the most likely to see upward spending in the next two years.
Register for Wall Street & Technology Newsletters
White Papers
Current Issue
Wall Street & Technology - July 2014
In addition to regular audits, the SEC will start to scrutinize the cyber-security preparedness of market participants.
Stressed Out by Compliance, Reputational Damage & Fines?
Stressed Out by Compliance, Reputational Damage & Fines?
Financial services executives are living in a "regulatory pressure cooker." Here's how executives are preparing for the new compliance requirements.