Wall Street & Technology: Blog
subscribe March 31, 2008

Could Lehman Bros have prevented latest fraud?

Lehman Bros has filed a lawsuit against Marubeni Corp., the Japanese trading giant, responsible for defrauding the New York-based investment bank out of US$352 million through a scam carried out by two rogue employees.

This latest incident – just weeks after the Soc Gen scandal – once again throws the spotlight on risk management practices.

The fraud happened when late last year, a unit of the New York-based investment bank issued loans to a fund run by a medical consulting company owned by LTT Bio-Pharma Co, a Tokyo-based biotech company.

The funds were supposed be used to help provide trade financing for hospitals buying medical equipment. They were secured with certificates from Marubeni Corp, one of Japan's biggest trading firms.

As the two Marubeni employees carried out the scam, they took the letterhead of Marubeni, forged an official seal from one of the heads of the Tokyo firm and hosted Lehman's reps in their offices, explains Philip Silitschanu, senior analyst at Aite Group.

"They were setting up a loan from Lehman that was supposedly going to the biopharmaceutical company. But essentially they were borrowing the money, and forging the loan to get the money themselves," he explains.

But Silitschanu says the bigger issue here is that this scenario is "the perfect storm in the industry of two very bad phenomena."

He points to the lending crisis and credit crunch, as well as serious loopholes in risk control systems.

"You're starting to see a new hybrid of bad lending/bad borrowing mixed with less than optimal risk control - forming the rogue borrower syndrome . It's a whole new concern," he says.

So how could Lehman have prevented this fraud? Silitschanu suggests it could have been as simple as not trusting two people in a huge firm.

"If they had asked just one more person in the firm, in theory they could have discovered that the whole thing was a sham," he adds.

Silitschanu says incidents such as the one at Lehman Bros and Soc Gen are making risk managers look beyond thir firm's own walls, and worry about the potential risk of rogue traders and rogue borrowers.

Unfortunately, the financial industry is much more reactive than proactive, Silitschanu says. "For a long time risk managers saw their job as dotting the "I"s, crossing the "t"s and setting up systems to follow the rules – that's it.

But since Soc Gen, when all the risk controls were hit, things may have started changing. "We're seeing risk managers say, 'We have to be proactive.'

"They have to start thinking of their role of risk managers as head of the financial safety of the firm, and start thinking like the criminals do," he suggests.

"But we are now noticing a larger number of clients asking more about risk management systems," he adds.

Posted by Melanie Rodier at 05:49 PM



This is a public forum. CMP Media and its affiliates are not responsible for and do not control what is posted herein. CMP Media makes no warranties or guarantees concerning any advice dispensed by its staff members or readers.

Community standards in this comment area do not permit hate language, excessive profanity, or other patently offensive language. Please be aware that all information posted to this comment area becomes the property of CMP Media LLC and may be edited and republished in print or electronic format as outlined in CMP Media's Terms of Service.

Important Note: This comment area is NOT intended for commercial messages or solicitations of business.


Greg MacSweeny Columns

Greg MacSweeney
Overbearing Market Reform Will Only Slow Market Innovation
As investors call for extensive regulatory oversight of certain derivatives, regulators mu...

What You Don’t Know Will Hurt You

Wall Street Changes Are Visible

The Term Web 2.0 Is Fading Away

CHECK THIS OUT

Novell Real Time Linux Webcast Series
In order to succeed, companies must be able to respond quickly, deliver superior value and quality of service, and carefully manage their costs. In this series of brief webcasts, you will learn how SUSE Linux Enterprise Real Time from Novell enables organizations to respond quicker by delivering low latencies, deliver increased value with fast response times, and better manage costs.

Events

Live Events:
Buy-Side Trading Xchange
June 04, 2008

Buy-Side Trading Summit 2008
November 16-18, 2008


Web Events:
2008 Market Mandates and Rich Internet Application Trending for Online Business Banking Channels 2008
May 20, 2008

How Can Financial Firms Build a Better Data Center?
May 29, 2008

Market Trends 2008 and Rich Internet Applications: Online Channels Retirement and Benefits Service Portals
June 03, 2008

Market Trends 2008 - Rich Internet Applications: Next Generation Online Financial Portals in Financial Services
June 04, 2008

Straight Talk About Low-Latency: The Value of a Millisecond
June 19, 2008


White Papers

Level 3 Connectivity Kit
Stay ahead of the bandwidth curve. The Level 3 Connectivity Kit provides full resources to help you make informed decisions regarding your network infrastructure. Download the Data Center Networking Strategies for Financial Services Firms White Paper; Business Class Ethernet: Trends in Perspective eBook and BC/DR Best Practices for the Data-Intensive Enterprise Gartner Webcast

Surviving and Thriving in a Challenging Market
Learn how financial services firms can use customer-centric strategies and tools to maximize client value and loyalty, gain insight into new opportunities, and do more with less, counteracting market volatility.

Marketplace

Career Center


Ready to take that job and shove it?

Function:
Information Technology
Engineering
State:


Keyword(s):

Browse By:
State | City