Most Read
- SEC Short Sale Rule Could Create a Bubble in Financial Stocks
- Cisco Global Exchange Study Ranks Latency Among Top Success Factors in Competitive Race
- Analytics Help Firms Turn Data Into Opportunity
- Wall Street Outsourcing to New, Exotic Corners of the Globe
- DTCC, Markit to Create Single Point of Derivatives Confirmation
- NYC Financial Firms to Get New Disaster Recovery Data Center in Pennsylvania
- TradeStation Unveils Flat-Fee Commissions for Active Traders
- Trading Desks Turn to Video Game Technology to Speed Analytics
Wall Street is Subtracting Value from America, Bogle Says
This morning we came across a fascinating conversation between Bill Moyers and John Bogle, founder of Vanguard, that took place during an episode of Bill Moyers Journal. To read the entire transcript, click here. Bogle basically asserted that Wall Street is ruining our society.
Here's an excerpt:
BILL MOYERS: What is the job of capitalism?
JOHN BOGLE: Well, ultimately, the job of capitalism is to serve the consumer. Serve the citizenry. You're allowed to make a profit for that. But, you've got to provide good products and services at fair prices. And that's the long term, that's what businesses do in the long term. The businesses that have endured in America have done that and done that successfully.
But, in the short term, there's all these financial machinations in which people can get very rich in a very short period of time by creating highly complex financial instruments, providing services that can be cut back easily as in the hospital article, not measuring up to basically their duty.
We all know that in professions, the idea has been service to the client before service to self. That's what a profession is. That's what medicine was. That's what accountancy was. That's what attorneys used to be. That's what trusteeship used to be inside the mutual fund industry. But, we've moved from that to a big capital accumulation — self interest — creating wealth for the providers of these services when the providers of these services are in fact subtracting value from society. So, it doesn't work.
BILL MOYERS: So, the private equity nursing homes have added to their wealth. But, they've subtracted from society the care for people who need it.
JOHN BOGLE: That is exactly correct. Not good.
BILL MOYERS: THE WALL STREET JOURNAL editorial page celebrates what it called the animal spirits of business. And as if that's the heart of capitalism. What do you think about that?
JOHN BOGLE: Well, I like the animal spirits of business. I mean Lord Keynes told us about animal spirits. And it comes out of a part of his work that says, "You know, all the precise numbers and the perspectives mean nothing. What determines the future of a business is its animal spirits." You know, the desire for progress, the desire to create something new. That's all good. But, it's gotten misshapen. Badly--
BILL MOYERS: How so?
JOHN BOGLE: --misshapen.
BILL MOYERS: How so?
JOHN BOGLE: Well, it's gotten misshapen because the financial side of the economy is dominating the productive side of the economy
BILL MOYERS: What do you mean?
JOHN BOGLE: Well, let me say it very simply. The rewards of the growth in our economy comes from corporate, largely - from corporations who are a very important measure, from corporations that are providing goods and services at a fair price innovating and bringing in new technology — providing a higher quality of life for our society and they make money doing it. I mean, and the returns in business in the long run are 100 percent the dividends a corporation pays and the rate at which its earnings grow.
That still exists. But, it's been overwhelmed by a financial economy. The financial economy, which is the way you package all these ways of financing corporations, more and more complex, more and more expensive. The financial sector of our economy is the largest profit-making sector in America. Our financial services companies make more money than our energy companies — no mean profitable business in this day and age. Plus, our healthcare companies. They make almost twice as much as our technology companies, twice as much as our manufacturing companies. We've become a financial economy which has overwhelmed the productive economy to the detriment of investors and the detriment ultimately of our society.
BILL MOYERS: By the financial sector, you mean?
JOHN BOGLE: Banks, money managers, insurance companies, certainly annuity providers. They're all subtracting value from the economy. They have to subtract. To be clear on this now — I don't want to overstate it. To be clear on this, they have to subtract some value. But, the question is--
BILL MOYERS: What do you mean they subtract some value?
JOHN BOGLE: In other words, — you've go to pay somebody something to provide a service. It's just gotten totally out of hand. My estimate is that the financial sector takes $560 billion a year out of society. Five hundred and sixty billion.
BILL MOYERS: Where does it go?
JOHN BOGLE: It goes into the pockets of hedge fund managers, mutual fund managers, bankers, insurance companies. Let me give you this just one little example. If you didn't make a $129 million last year — I'm presuming that you didn't. You don't rank among the highest paid 25 hedge fund managers. A $129 million doesn't get you into the upper echelon.
BILL MOYERS: And on the way here this morning, I saw a story that now a $1 billion will not get you in the FORTUNE 400. A $1 billion!
JOHN BOGLE: Well, I spend a lot of time thinking about that. I mean, you kind of asked the question, which I've asked in some of my work. What is enough here? And the society is out of control. I mean, in THE BATTLE FOR THE SOUL OF CAPITALISM, I talk about the frightening similarities between the American economy in America, our nation, at the beginning of the 21st century and Rome all those centuries ago around the 4th century.
BILL MOYERS: What are the comparisons?
JOHN BOGLE: We have an idea that we are the world's value creator and leader. And I'm talking not just about economic value, but, we like to think of America as having the best values of integrity and citizenship in the world. We're getting a little bit too much self interested. We have our own bread and circuses. And they're a little different than the bread and circuses they had in Rome. But, we surely have our circuses whether it's sports teams or casino gambling or the lottery in the states. And we see this not just in our economy, in our financial system. This very short-term focus on everything. You see it, sadly, in our government.
Everybody knows social security is going to run into crisis. We can't run these federal deficits forever. But, everybody looks out two years and says, "Will I be elected two years from now or a year and a half from now?" And, the short term focus ultimately betrays the very values that we have come to be used to in this great nation of ours.
Posted by Penny Crosman at 10:29 AM
This is a public forum. CMP Media and its affiliates are not responsible for and do not control what is posted herein. CMP Media makes no warranties or guarantees concerning any advice dispensed by its staff members or readers.
Community standards in this comment area do not permit hate language, excessive profanity, or other patently offensive language. Please be aware that all information posted to this comment area becomes the property of CMP Media LLC and may be edited and republished in print or electronic format as outlined in CMP Media's Terms of Service.
Important Note: This comment area is NOT intended for commercial messages or solicitations of business.
Greg MacSweeny Columns
Greg MacSweeneyIn a Matter of Months, CIOs’ Agendas Turned Upside Down
Early in the summer of 2007, Wall Street was counting its good fortune. In early summer 20...
Former CIO Gavazzi Launches Risk Alert Provider
Where Are They Now? Life After Wall Street
Where Are They Now? Mitchel Lenson, Former Deutsche Bank Group CIO
Larry Tabb Columns
Larry TabbClearing and Settlement Top-of-Mind for Front-Office Execs
In addition to the excitement in the U.S., the real focus is occurring in Europe, where th...
Risk Management IT Comes to the Forefront in the Wake of Subprime Credit Crisis
In a Tumultuous Economy, Wall Street Must -- and Will -- Find a New Model
CHECK THIS OUTNovell Real Time Linux Webcast SeriesIn order to succeed, companies must be able to respond quickly, deliver superior value and quality of service, and carefully manage their costs. In this series of brief webcasts, you will learn how SUSE Linux Enterprise Real Time from Novell enables organizations to respond quicker by delivering low latencies, deliver increased value with fast response times, and better manage costs. |
EventsLive Events:Accelerating Wall Street 2 October 02, 2008 Buy-Side Trading Summit 2008 November 16-18, 2008 |
White PapersLevel 3 Connectivity KitStay ahead of the bandwidth curve. The Level 3 Connectivity Kit provides full resources to help you make informed decisions regarding your network infrastructure. Download the Data Center Networking Strategies for Financial Services Firms White Paper; Business Class Ethernet: Trends in Perspective eBook and BC/DR Best Practices for the Data-Intensive Enterprise Gartner Webcast Surviving and Thriving in a Challenging Market Learn how financial services firms can use customer-centric strategies and tools to maximize client value and loyalty, gain insight into new opportunities, and do more with less, counteracting market volatility. |
Marketplace |
Career CenterReady to take that job and shove it?
|
Most Recent Job Posts:
* Lowe's seeking Manager of IT Research in Mooresville, NC
* Hebrew Senior Life seeking Senior Informatics Analyst in Roslindale, MA * UCLA seeking Programmer/Analyst IV in Los Angeles, CA * T-Mobile seeking Program Manager 3 in Snoqualmie, WA * Comcast seeking Tier 4 CRAN Network Engineer in Chelmsford, MA For more tech jobs in the industry, visit Wall Street & Technology's Career Portal. |









